Top Shows

Contact ONE News

Tim Watkin: Poll kick in the pants for Labour


Published: 6:19PM Sunday April 01, 2012 Source: ONE News

  • David Shearer makes his debut as Labour leader in the debating chamber (Source: ONE News)
    David Shearer makes his debut as Labour leader in the debating chamber - Source: ONE News

The latest One News-Colmar Brunton poll is a kick in the pants for Labour. After a ministerial resignation and a fortnight where the whiff of cronyism was never far from National's door, it can still command more than 50 percent support in the polls. That's astounding.

The suggestion is that voters don't much care about the whole ACC-Bronwyn Pullar saga. Oh, it's good theatre and they'd hate to think anyone was getting special treatment, but it's not enough for them to switch sides. They can see that a minister has gone, so 'something has been done'. They see a woman on a lonely crusade and think 'that's hardly National's fault'. They see former National Party president Michelle Boag in the gun, but don't think of that as a reflection on the current government.

And they hear John Key say time and again that if there was any real cronyism going on, Pullar would be in a better position after ten years than she is now. The fact she hasn't got her way is proof of no cronyism.

Except it isn't. John Key can't say that the intervention of Smith, Boag, or anyone else hasn't influenced the way ACC has handled this case; only the ACC staff on the receiving end can say whether they felt pressured by Pullar's National Party mates. And as Fran O'Sullivan pointed out on Q+A this Sunday:

"I want to challenge the notion that the prime minister put there that, you know, there's been no undue influence because this thing's gone on for 10 years and hasn't been settled. Well, actually, it may have gone on for 10 years because of undue influence. This thing, you know, this benefit may have actually been brought to a point three, five, six years ago. I don't know. It seems a very long time for somebody to be on an ACC benefit who's already had a large pay-out from an insurance company as well."

All of which suggests a more thorough inquiry than the Privacy Commissioner can effect is the only way for the air to be cleared.

The PM, though, is unmoved by that argument. For now at least. And this poll result - and the private polling National will be doing - is the reason for that. None of this is hurting his party; not much anyway.

The real pain must be felt by Labour. While National is under attack from within and ministers are looking rugged, to say the least, the opposition isn't benefiting. Voters clearly don't yet see Labour as a viable alternative government. David Shearer is not the 'go to' guy for voters to run to. Some inside Labour may say 'give us a chance, it's only April'. But if they can't make hay now, when can they?

The problem is that even a damaged National Party still looks more attractive to most voters than Labour. Voters are looking at National in turmoil and still ticking their box. If that's not a signal that Labour needs to up its game dramatically, then I don't know what is.

Read more Tim Watkin opinion