Abbott under fire over savings claims

Published: 3:48PM Thursday September 02, 2010 Source: AAP

  • Print this article
  • Text size + -

A hole in the opposition's election costings uncovered by Treasury and worth at least $7 billion has put a dent in the coalition's bid to form a minority government.

The finding, as revealed to the three independent MPs on today, has forced at least one - New England MP Tony Windsor - to question his possible support for Tony Abbott.

He has urged the coalition to explain the discrepancy in estimated budget savings - as unveiled by Treasury - which stands between $7 billion and $11 billion.

While refusing to say if it will sway his final decision, Windsor said it has made him suspicious about Abbott and whether the coalition can be trusted.

"We probably understand now why he wasn't interested in releasing the numbers," Windsor told ABC Television.

"One of (the) things that we have to establish is trust in what they're actually saying."

Fellow independent Rob Oakeshott claims the jury's still out on the coalition's costings.

Labor has seized on Treasury's assessment, accusing the coalition of either "deliberate dishonesty or incompetence, or both".

Treasurer Wayne Swan said there were problems with the coalition's sums relating to the national broadband network, which it wants to scrap, and an undercosted paid parental leave.

"These are mistakes and deliberate dishonesty," he told ABC Radio.

But the opposition was out in force on Thursday, arguing its figures still stood up to scrutiny.

"It's a matter of difference of opinion, it's not a matter of error," opposition finance spokesman Andrew Robb said, arguing Treasury used different models and data in its assessment.

Opposition treasury spokesman Joe Hockey denied the costings debate would sway the independents against the coalition, saying he'd already spoken to Oakeshott.

"We stand by emphatically our policies and our numbers," he said.

"We think we are absolutely right on these figures."

He said the coalition and Treasury agreed on "96%" of the figures, although Hockey is expected to return to Treasury in a bid to clarify the discrepancies.

Windsor, Oakeshott and fellow independent Bob Katter remain in Canberra on Thursday as they attempt to make up their mind about the next government.

Along with independent MP Andrew Wilkie, it's hoped they will come to a decision by early next week.

Meanwhile, the coalition are still battling to woo WA Nationals MP Tony Crook, who maintains he'll sit on the crossbenches if he doesn't get millions of dollars for regional infrastructure.

"Mr Abbott has my phone number," he told ABC Radio.

  • Print this article
  • Text size + -
  • more...

World News Video

World News

Most Popular

  1. Gales forecast to lash much of the country
  2. Princess reveals Queen's private side
  3. Undercover report exposes elderly care industry
  4. 'Child porn' found on Megaupload servers by FBI
  5. Another suspicious fire in Kaiapoi

rssLatest News

Advertising

How do you want your news?

  • Mobile Devices

    TVNZ is available on mobile phones: Text TVNZ to 8869.

  • News Feeds

    See when TVNZ have added new content. You can get the latest headlines anywhere.

  • Podcasts

    Enjoy TVNZ on the move - a wide range of programmes and highlights are available.