Published: 6:34PM Wednesday September 07, 2005
Source: AAP
"For God's sake, are you blind?," a woman shouts at the head of
America's Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), Michael
Brown. "You're patting each other on the back, while people here
are dying."
The woman is not a victim of Hurricane Katrina. She is a reporter
with US television network MSNBC who is so affected by the misery
she has witnessed she can hold back no longer.
"Katrinagate" is the term being used by the media to describe the
biggest challenge facing the political establishment in the US
since the Watergate affair in the 1970s toppled Richard
Nixon.
Not for decades has there been such merciless questioning of the
president and his administration by the US media.
Even now, as the rescue operation gets underway in earnest and the
flood waters in New Orleans are starting to subside, the federal
government's inadequate reaction - in the run-up to the hurricane
and directly afterwards - is still being criticised by the media in
reports which are anything but detached.
Never before, say some observers, have US reporters been so
emotionally involved in a story to the point of being enraged. They
are not just telling a story, they have become part of it.
"Has Katrina saved the US media,?" asked BBC reporter Matt Wells
who sees the shift in tone as a potentially historic
development.
A number of US journalists who cover federal politics, especially
television presenters, had become part of the political
establishment, says Wells.
"They live in the same suburbs, go to the same parties. Their
television companies are owned by large conglomerates who
contribute to election campaigns."
It's a "perfect recipe" for fearful, self-censoring reportage, he
says, but thinks "since last week, that's all over".
But if the Bush administration's reaction to Hurricane Katrina was
slow, so too was the media's.
On Friday, reporters at the scene were still having difficulties
establishing the scale of the disaster and the number of
dead.
Used to reporting on comparatively harmless storms, heroically
riding out the storms with windblown hairdos, they were then
confronted with the "Big One".
The television reporters, particularly, were left scrambling in the
first few hours of coverage as they tried to comprehend the scale
of the disaster.
Then came the emotion. A CNN reporter broke down as she described
the cries of help of people stuck on rooftops in Louisiana. Other
journalists also related what they saw in broken voices.
Then the federal officials rolled into town and the press
conferences started, with politicians thanking one another for
their tireless efforts.
Next came anger. "This isn't Iraq, this isn't Somalia, this is our
home," one NBC television reporter shouted.
The usually stoic ABC television presenter Ted Koeppel lashed out
at FEMA head Brown in a interview, when he could not give any
details on the number of refugees waiting to be rescued from the
Convention Centre.
"Don't you people ever look at television?," the veteran presenter
raged. "Don't you ever hear the radio? We've been reporting on the
crisis at the Convention Centre for a lot longer than just
today."
A CNN journalist also attacked Brown. "How it is possible that we
have better information than you? Why aren't supplies being dropped
in (by plane). In Banda Aceh, in Indonesia, they did it two days
after the tsunami."
Another CNN reporter interrupted Senator Mary Landrieu during an
interview in which she was praising Congress for passing an
emergency aid package.
"Excuse me Senator, I'm sorry for interrupting. I haven't heard
anything about that, because I was busy these past four days seeing
dead people on the street. And when I hear how one politician
congratulating the others...Yesterday there was a corpse on the
street which had been eaten by rats because it had been there for
48 hours."
If the alarm bells are not already going off in the Oval Office,
they should be, because the previously staunchly pro-Bush Fox News
is also starting to show signs of disaffection.
As one of their reporters was being directed to another area
because of the danger caused by looting, he spoke quickly into his
microphone, saying: "These people are desperate. Why shouldn't they
try to steal water and food from us?"
Advertising