Evangelical Christians, buoyed by the re-election of Republican
President George W. Bush, are turning American schools into a
battleground over whether evolution explains the origins of life or
whether nature was designed by an all-powerful force.
In at least 18 states, campaigns have begun to make public schools
teach "intelligent design" - a theory that nature is so complex it
could only have been created by design - alongside Charles Darwin's
theory of evolution.
"It's pretty clear that there is a religious movement behind
intelligent design," said Steve Case, chairman of the Science
Standards Committee, a group of educators that advises the Kansas
Board of Education. The board will decide later this year whether
to include intelligent design in biology classes.
Some scientists who espouse the theory say intelligent design does
not question that evolution occurred but how it occurred: they
believe more was at play than random mutation and natural
selection. The theory, they insist, does not support the religious
concept of a creator.
Those who advocate giving it equal treatment in schools have a
different interpretation.
"Intelligent design promotes a rational basis for belief in God,"
said John Calvert, managing director of the Kansas-based advocacy
group Intelligent Design Network Inc.
Americans' resistance to evolution is nothing new.
In 1925, Tennessee high school biology teacher John Scopes was
prosecuted for teaching evolution in violation of a state law
favouring creationism in one of the most celebrated trials in US
history. Scopes was convicted and fined $US100 and the Tennessee
Supreme Court overturned the verdict on a technicality.
Critics, civil liberties groups and many biology teachers, see
intelligent design being used as a version of creationism - the
theory that God created the world as described in Genesis. The US
Supreme Court barred public school teaching of creationism in the
1980s for violating the separation of church and state.
Push from Bush voters
They say the push for intelligent design in America's schools comes
from evangelical Christians, a group key to Bush winning a second
term last November.
Supporters have proposed laws in state assemblies, campaigned for
new policies at state and local school boards, and placed stickers
in textbooks saying evolution is controversial and that students
should consider alternatives.
The Dover Area School Board in Pennsylvania now requires that
ninth-graders are told there are "gaps" in the theory of evolution,
and that intelligent design is an alternative they should consider.
The American Civil Liberties Union has challenged the policy in
court as unconstitutional.
A bill in Missouri would require public school biology textbooks to
contain a "critical analysis of origins" and highlight
controversial topics "such as biological evolution."
According to the National Council for Science Education, a
pro-evolution group in Oakland, California, other states
considering legislation on the issue include Georgia, South
Carolina, Mississippi, Montana, Oklahoma, Alabama, and Texas. Other
state or local school boards debating the teaching of intelligent
design include Ohio, Arkansas, Wisconsin, Kansas, Wisconsin,
Maryland, Michigan, Tennessee and Alaska.
Most Americans believe in some form of creationism, according to a
CBS poll conducted ahead of last November's election. 55% of
Americans believed God created humans in their present form and a
further 27% believed humans evolved, but God guided the
process.
65% of all Americans favoured schools teaching creationism and
evolution while 37% wanted creationism taught instead of
evolution.
The poll found greater support for teaching creationism among
Republican voters - 71% of Bush voters favoured teaching
creationism alongside evolution.
One noted proponent of intelligent design complicates the debate by
arguing it should not be taught in high school.
John West, a senior fellow at the Seattle-based Discovery
Institute, which pioneered intelligent design research, said the
theory was too complex to teach at high schools and was better
suited to a college setting.
"There is a concern that intelligent design has been hijacked by
people who don't really know what it says," he said. "We don't
think it should be a political football."
Many biology teachers, such as those in Pennsylvania who refused to
read the school board's statement on intelligent design to
students, say the theory is not scientific.
"Intelligent design is a religious doctrine," said Wayne Carley,
executive director of the National Association of Biology Teachers.
"There is no research to support it, and it is clearly religious in
that it posits a higher being."
Carley conceded the battle against the teaching of intelligent
design is a hard one to win because proponents approach the issue
as one of faith rather than rationality.
"We can argue that it's bad science but people don't want to hear
that," he said. "They are coming from a much more basic gut
level."
How do you want your news
-
Email
Choose the news you want when you want it, all in one personalised daily e-mail.
-
Mobile Devices
TVNZ is available on mobile phones: Text TVNZ to 8869.
-
News Feeds
See when TVNZ have added new content. You can get the latest headlines anywhere.
-
Podcasts
Enjoy TVNZ on the move - a wide range of programmes and highlights are available.