End of the line for Super 14 rugby?

Published: 5:50PM Monday May 11, 2009 Source: Reuters

  • Print this article
  • Text size + -

In a week in which the Super 14 playoff positions will be decided, southern hemisphere rugby bosses head to Dublin where they will attempt to resolve the competition's future.

Seven sides remain in contention for the playoffs, with the last round robin match between South Africa's Bulls and Sharks in Durban likely to determine the semi-finalists.

Off the field, however, South Africa, Australia and New Zealand rugby (SANZAR) administrators have been engaged in a game of brinkmanship that many are hoping will be settled, one way or another, at an IRB meeting this week.

SANZAR have been attempting to iron out an agreement on the future of an expanded Super rugby competition to begin in 2011 for at least a year and time is fast running out.

They have until June 30 to present broadcasters with a proposal for a new competition and television contract that provides the bulk of the revenue for professional rugby in the three countries and have so far failed to reach an agreement.

As such, Australia and New Zealand said they had developed a contingency plan that would see them go it alone with the intent to eventually expand a trans-Tasman competition into Japan and the Pacific Islands.

While both NZRU chief executive Steve Tew and ARU managing director John O'Neill have said it was their preference to continue a Super rugby format with South Africa, the fact that plans are so advanced indicates their willingness to walk away.

Local media have also begun to jump on the bandwagon, believing the Super rugby format has become stale and that something needs to be done to reinvigorate the tournament.

Timing issue

At issue is the timing of the competition, with South Africa refusing to move from the current early February start in order to protect their domestic Currie Cup competition later in the year.

The Australasians, however, want the competition to begin in March allowing their cricket seasons to end and giving the test players a longer break from end-of-year tours to Europe. A conference-based system is also preferred, allowing for more local derbies and for the competition to extend to 22 weeks into August, which would clash with the Currie Cup and New Zealand's domestic provincial tournaments.

Speculation is rife that South Africa are prepared to throw their lot in with European competitions and while flights to and from Europe would still be 12 hours, the similar time zones are more beneficial to players and television audiences.

Where to place the South Africans in a congested European calendar, however, would create a dilemma for northern administrators and O'Neill told a Sydney radio station on Monday he expected talk of any movement north was a "bluff".

A potential expansion to a Super 15, which had been mooted if SANZAR remained intact, was also proving a sticking point.

South African Rugby Union (SARU) have begun to flex their muscles on getting a sixth team into a Super 15 with the newly-formed Southern Kings to play the British and Irish Lions in Port Elizabeth on June 16.

O'Neill has said he would prefer a 15th team to be based in Australia, though one of the arguments against that proposal is the lack of depth within Australia's player pool, where rugby competes with rugby league, Australian rules and soccer.

If the Australasians do go it alone, O'Neill and Tew have said the financial implications would not be as bad as initially envisaged, with the former adding a move into Japan, which he has long advocated, was commercially attractive to broadcasters.

Whatever the outcome of the last ditch meeting on Thursday in Dublin, any future competition is likely to be vastly different from that which fans will watch this weekend.

  • Print this article
  • Text size + -
  • more...

Rugby Video

How do you want your news?

  • Mobile Devices

    TVNZ is available on mobile phones: Text TVNZ to 8869.

  • News Feeds

    See when TVNZ have added new content. You can get the latest headlines anywhere.

  • Podcasts

    Enjoy TVNZ on the move - a wide range of programmes and highlights are available.