Bain dealing with trial trauma: Lawyer

Published: 7:03AM Saturday June 06, 2009 Source: NZPA/ONE News

  • Print this article
  • Text size + -

David Bain restarts his life on Saturday - his name cleared after being acquitted on Friday of murdering his family - but it will take him a long time to get over the trauma of his trial, his lawyer Michael Reed QC says.
 
Bain, 37, was clearly shaky outside the court after a High Court jury in Christchurch cleared him of the murders of his parents Robin and Margaret, sisters Arawa and Laniet and brother Stephen.

He spent 13 years in prison after being found guilty at his first trial. The Privy Council quashed the convictions two years ago and the Solicitor General ordered a new trial one year ago.

Bain appeared outside the courthouse with his chief supporter Joe Karam but apart from thanking Karam and his supporters, he did not say much, struggling for words amid the emotion of the moment.

"He was just overwhelmed, he actually could not speak, he was so upset," Reed told Close-Up.

"He is not coping at the moment. This struggle of his, three months in court, seeing his family on the morgue table and in pieces, I mean how does he cope?

"It is going to take him a long time. I just hope some of the family who could have supported him will maybe give back the money they got from the estate, I mean he has got no money."

The Karam family and friends of Bain have set up a website to raise money for him to "kick-start" his new life.

Bain has a message on the website, thanking his friends and supporters and defence team.

"Friends past and present, with your love and support, I have cleared my name as I vowed to do 15 years ago."

At the celebration party on Friday night, Bain described the jury's verdict, after just under six hours of deliberation, as "a huge release" and a "huge weight off his shoulders".

Reed said one advantage in Bain's favour in adjusting to a new life was his personality.
 
"He is such a nice guy, he's a gentleman, he's courteous, he's got a great sense of humour. He really is a nice guy and I don't think he did it for a moment."
 
Reed also called on the government to be generous to Bain financially.

A claim is likely to be made for compensation given the acquittals. Justice Minister Simon Power said on Friday any application would probably be referred to a senior lawyer to consider and would be judged on its merits. He warned there was no legal right to compensation.

Police accept verdict

Police say they will not pursue the case any further.

"We are disappointed with the outcome but accept the jury's decision," says Detective Superintendent Malcolm Burgess.

The defence maintained David's father Robin killed the family before turning the gun on himself but the prosecution said there was no forensic evidence to show Robin Bain was the killer.

Police are standing by the investigation they undertook in 1994 saying it was thorough and impartial.

"The material presented as evidence over the past few months is essentially the same material presented in the first trial," says Burgess.

Bain's supporters have long claimed that police bungled the scene examination, got critical timings wrong, made a premature arrest and that evidence was made to fit.

"As with all investigations, there are things we could do differently and things that we learn.

"However we need to remember these events happened in 1994. Procedures are different now - there is better forensic testing and improved investigation procedures for dealing with investigations," says Burgess.

  • Print this article
  • Text size + -
  • more...

David Bain News

Most Popular

  1. Corby worse than a terrorist: judge
  2. One Direction fan sneaks into dressing room
  3. Strong quake hits Christchurch watch
  4. Two men arrested after protest outside Auckland hotel watch
  5. English suggests jobless move to Christchurch watch

rssLatest News

Advertising

How do you want your news?

  • Mobile Devices

    TVNZ is available on mobile phones: Text TVNZ to 8869.

  • News Feeds

    See when TVNZ have added new content. You can get the latest headlines anywhere.

  • Podcasts

    Enjoy TVNZ on the move - a wide range of programmes and highlights are available.