Black Caps v Zimbabwe ODI series report card

Max Bania opinion

By Max Bania

Published: 9:57AM Friday February 10, 2012 Source: ONE Sport

  • Print this article
  • Text size + -

Rob Nicol. 3 matches, 207 runs at 69, strike rate 102.
Jesse Ryder's return to the top of the order may not quite be pre-ordained just yet after Nicol staked his claim for an extended run as an opener. A slow and sensible starter, he burst into life both in Whangarei and Napier to lay the foundation for 350-plus scores. Also finished as the series' joint-top wicket taker with his probing off-spinners, thanks mainly to a career-best 4-19 in Dunedin where Zimbabwe's aggresive batsman just couldn't get near him.
Grade: A

Martin Guptill. 3 matches, 232 runs at 77.3, SR 108.
It's wonderful to see a New Zealand batsman in such a prodigious vein of form and scoring so consistently. Guptill is simply a colossus at the crease at the moment; whether he's leaning back to hammer a pull shot onto the roof or striding out to send a half-volley sailing back over the sightscreen. Loses a mark though for failing to convert any of his three fifties into hundreds: when you're in this sort of form, you have to make the most of it.
Grade: A

Jacob Oram. 2 matches, 84 runs at 42, SR 162. 3 wickets at 15.3, ER 3.3.
By no means an automatic selections for this series, the oldest member of the squad rolled back the years to ensure that he will be for the rest of the summer. Used as a pinch hitter in the final two games, Oram carried on the openers' good work by striking some massive blows of his own. Less of a surprise was his unerring medium pace bowling, which these days is a valuable enough asset on its own to secure his place in the XI.|
Grade: A

Brendon McCullum. 3 matches, 142 runs at 47.3, SR 130.
Made up for the stark disappointment of missing out on his home ground in Dunedin by scoring a superbly-paced 119 in Napier. It was a welcome return to a finishing role that McCullum filled so well in tandem with the likes of Oram and Craig McMillan five or six years ago. Handed an easy first full series as captain, McCullum hardly missed a beat, setting adventurous but calculated fields and rotating his bowlers well. A general as ever behind the stumps.
Grade: A-

Kane Williamson. 3 matches, 77 runs at 25.7, SR 76. 3 wickets at 9.7, ER 4.8.
A series of cameos for the youngster - as more of a worker and stroker of the ball, he was never likely to have the same impact as his big-hitting colleagues. Steadied the ship in Dunedin after the loss of two early wickets but then perished at an inopportune moment and was out again in the 30s in Whangarei as he tried to up the ante with his captain. Collected the two lower order wickets in Napier to boost his bowling average.
Grade: B

Dean Brownlie. 2 matches, 21 runs at 21, SR 70.
Played a peripheral role in the first two matches before breaking a bone in his finger while fielding in Napier. Looked like setting up a big finish to the innings before being needlessly run out in Dunedin. Will likely miss the South African ODI series through injury, and given the successful start to his Test career, it must be tempting for the selectors to allow Brownlie to develop that part of his game exclusively.
Grade: B

Tom Latham. 3 matches, 79 runs at 39.5, SR 123.
After a nervous start in Dunedin, the teenager seemed perfectly at home within the New Zealand set up. Struck some glorious blows during the final overs assault in Whangarei, while his second-ball six onto the roof in the final game would've made father Rod proud. May not be deemed ready for the challenge of South Africa but certainly did his long term Black Caps prospects no harm.
Grade: A-

Nathan McCullum. 2 matches, 51 runs at 25.5, SR 104. 2 wickets at 20, ER 5.0.
Another middle order player reduced to later overs cameos. McCullum made a steadying 30 in Dunedin before playing a horrible shot which ultimately led to his team being bowled out inside the 50 overs. In Napier, he took full toll of some awful death bowling to crack 21 off seven balls. Didn't play a huge role with the ball but is an efficient operator in all disciplines of the game and should see more game time against the Proteas.
Grade: B

Andrew Ellis. 3 matches, 45 runs at 22.5, SR 122. 1 wicket at 88, ER 4.2.
Another newbie who looked assured making the (albeit slight) step up to the international arena. Ellis made a very composed run-a-ball 33 in Dunedin in his only real chance to impress with the bat. A solitary wicket failed to reflect some probing and accurate spells with the ball. Tidy both in the infield and out, he was rewarded with a call-up to the Twenty20 squad in the absence of Dean Brownlie.|
Grade: B

Tarun Nethula. 2 matches, 2 wicket at 48, ER 4.8.
A contrasting debut series for Nethula: after a nervous debut in Whangarei, he found his feet and bowled a superb spell in Napier. The sight of Zimbabwe's batsmen prodding helplessly at his leg-spinners became almost comical as he scooped 2-41. Great to see a leggie playing for New Zealand turning it plenty as well; now all eyes turn to Ronnie Hira to see if he can impress during the Twenty20s.
Grade: B

Doug Bracewell. 2 matches, 2 wickets at 29.5, ER 3.7.
Surprisingly, this was as much a series for the spinners as the fast bowlers but Bracewell still impressed; taking an excellent caught and bowled in Dunedin and bowling tidily again in Napier. Again showed his ability to move the ball in the air and off the seam and at good pace - far too hot for the tourists to handle.
Grade: B

Kyle Mills. 2 matches, 5 wickets at 10.6, ER 3.3
Clearly New Zealand's best-performed fast bowler, Mills just keeps getting the job done at limited overs level. Knocked the stuffing out of Zimbabwe's briefly-promising run chase in Dunedin and took two more wickets as the hosts strolled to victory in Whangarei as ever.
Grade: A

Tim Southee. 2 matches, one wicket at 77, ER 4.3.
Bowled a bit better than those figures suggest, but keen observers of the game seem to agree there's something not quite right with Southee at the moment. Whether it's a fault in his action or fatigue from being over-bowled, he lacked the usual spark in his two outings here; surprising given one of them was in front of his home crowd in Whangarei.
Grade: C

Michael Bates. 1 match, 1 wicket at 24, ER 3.0.
A touch unlucky in that he was the only squad member to only get one chance, and it came in a dead rubber. Bates shared the new ball with Doug Bracewell and kept all Zimbabwe's batsmen quiet, but didn't get the opportunity to show off his real talent as a cool and accurate death bowler.
Grade: B

Agree with the ratings? Comment below.

  • Print this article
  • Text size + -
  • more...

Add a Comment:

Post new comment

    Cricket News

    Most Popular

    1. Gritty Chiefs edge out Bulls in thriller watch
    2. Herbert signals few changes for All Whites
    3. As it happened: Chiefs v Bulls watch
    4. Dumped Schwalger to fight Samoan rugby
    5. Kirwan says coaching Blues would be an honour

    rssLatest News

    Advertising

    How do you want your news?

    • Mobile Devices

      TVNZ is available on mobile phones: Text TVNZ to 8869.

    • News Feeds

      See when TVNZ have added new content. You can get the latest headlines anywhere.

    • Podcasts

      Enjoy TVNZ on the move - a wide range of programmes and highlights are available.